It’s been interesting reading all of the press around the outing of Mike Daisey’s “coverage” of Apple’s manufacturing issues and specifically the retraction by This American Life of the content behind its most popular episode. John Gruber did one of the better take downs of the hypocracy behind Daisey’s story. SF Weekly also stands out getting to the heart of the matter — Daisey has probably done more to make people doubt the veracity of any story about Foxconn going forward.
But I think Jeff Yang of Wall Street Journal’s Speakeasy blog has one of the most interesting points-0f-view, comparing Daisey’s fabrications to Steve Jobs’s own reality distortion field:
People want to believe in Daisey’s stories, because they want to have faith in the ability of individuals to change the path of history with their actions. They want to believe they can think different, act different, and — as crazy as it sounds — make the world a better place. It is, again quite ironically, exactly the same enchantment Steve Jobs always depended on to sell his magical devices — you may not believe me, but you want to believe in me, and what I’m saying is that this is changing the game, changing the industry, changing the world.
I’ve always had a hard time with the idea of journalism as Truth with a capital T. Everyone has a bias and pretending otherwise is just dishonest. Clearly, journalists have a higher standard to tilt at than a marketer — or a storyteller — and Mike Daisey’s problem as much as anything else is that he slipped from storyteller into journalist, even if by omission. But the idea that Daisey the storyteller was playing by no different rules than Jobs the marketer is an interesting angle that I think is being underplayed here.
Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think Daisey is equivalent in stature to Steve Jobs any more than he is to Mark Twain (whose quote Daisey led off his blog post with). But there is nothing inherently wrong with using a reality distortion field to make a point. Daisey’s only failing (and I realize it’s a whopper) was to let people think he was a journalist. Oh, and writing this post. Don’t pretend that it‘s about truth when it really isn’t.